For years, right-wing media outlets like Fox News and Newsmax told their audiences what they wanted to hear: that Donald Trump didn’t lose the 2020 election. That Joe Biden’s victory was fraudulent. That shadowy companies and foreign actors had rigged the outcome. It was a story that electrified MAGA viewers and fueled Trump’s “Stop the Steal” movement.
But it wasn’t true. And now, the price tag for that falsehood is climbing into the billions.
Top Three Takeaways from the Article:
Election lies are costing billions – Fox News and Newsmax have paid massive settlements for knowingly spreading false claims about Trump’s 2020 loss, showing that misinformation now comes with a steep financial price.
False narratives had specific, fabricated details – From blaming Dominion and Smartmatic to wild conspiracies about Hugo Chávez and George Soros, right-wing outlets pushed demonstrably false stories to keep the MAGA base engaged.
Accountability is reshaping media strategy – With lawsuits mounting, misinformation is no longer just a political weapon but also a legal and financial liability that could force media companies to rethink their business models.
The Fox News Settlement: $787.5 Million to Dominion
Fox News paid an unprecedented $787.5 million settlement to Dominion Voting Systems in April 2023. The lawsuit exposed that Fox hosts, including Tucker Carlson, Sean Hannity, and Maria Bartiromo, aired false claims they knew were baseless.
Some of the specific lies Fox aired included:
- That Dominion was created in Venezuela to help Hugo Chávez rig elections.
- That Dominion had a secret tie to George Soros and global elites.
- That Dominion’s machines were programmed to switch Trump votes to Biden votes.
That ballots were manipulated using software “back doors” and foreign interference from China.
Internal communications released during the lawsuit revealed that Fox executives and hosts privately admitted they didn’t believe these claims but aired them anyway out of fear of losing Trump-loyal viewers to competitors like Newsmax.
The Newsmax Settlement: $67 Million to Investors
This week, Newsmax agreed to pay $67 million to settle a lawsuit from shareholders who claimed the company misled investors by peddling false election claims. This comes on top of other lawsuits, including one from Dominion still pending.
The false claims Newsmax promoted included:
- That Dominion and Smartmatic were part of a vast conspiracy to steal the election from Trump.
- That votes were manipulated through “international interference.”
- That dead people, undocumented immigrants, and “fake ballots” were counted in massive numbers.
Newsmax gave platforms to fringe attorneys like Sidney Powell and Rudy Giuliani, who spun elaborate conspiracy theories that were later laughed out of court.
Together, Fox and Newsmax have now shelled out over $850 million in settlements, with more lawsuits looming from Smartmatic and individuals defamed by the networks. If Smartmatic’s $2.7 billion suit against Fox is successful, the costs could dwarf even the Dominion settlement.
The lesson is clear: lying about elections is no longer just politically dangerous – it’s financially catastrophic.
What’s Next for Right-Wing Media?
The danger for outlets like Fox and Newsmax is that they built their business models around feeding outrage and confirming conspiracy theories. Backtracking risks alienating their loyal base, while doubling down invites more lawsuits.
Meanwhile, Trump continues to repeat the very lies that cost these networks nearly a billion dollars. The question is whether right-wing media will keep risking bankruptcy to keep pace with him, or whether the era of unchecked election disinformation is finally coming to a close.
Comments
No comments yet. Start the conversation.